Running Credit Checks on a Prospective Tenant: How Important is it?

Updated 11/8/24

Selecting the right tenant is one of the most crucial decisions for a landlord, impacting everything from property upkeep to timely rent payments. One essential tool for evaluating potential tenants is running credit checks on tenants. This practice provides landlords with valuable insights into an applicant’s financial responsibility, reliability, and overall creditworthiness, all of which are important indicators of whether they’ll make a dependable tenant. In this article, we’ll dive into why credit checks are so important, what information they reveal, and how landlords can conduct them effectively.

---

Table of Contents

1. Why Credit Checks Matter in Tenant Screening
2. What a Credit Check Can Reveal
3. How to Conduct a Tenant Credit Check
4. Common Concerns and Legal Considerations
5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

---

1. Why Credit Checks Matter in Tenant Screening

As a landlord, protecting your investment means thoroughly screening applicants before handing over the keys. Running credit checks on tenants is a fundamental part of this process, helping to assess a prospective tenant’s financial stability. A credit check provides a snapshot of their past financial behavior, helping landlords gauge whether the applicant will reliably pay rent and manage other financial responsibilities associated with the rental.

Credit checks also help landlords avoid potentially risky tenants who may have a history of defaulting on payments, accumulating significant debt, or being financially overextended. By incorporating credit checks into your screening process, you can make more informed decisions, reduce the chances of late payments or missed rent, and ultimately protect your property’s profitability.

2. What a Credit Check Can Reveal

A credit check offers more than just a credit score; it uncovers various financial details that can give landlords insight into a prospective tenant’s financial reliability. Here’s what you can expect to see when running credit checks on tenants:

• Credit Score: This three-digit number is a quick indicator of creditworthiness. Higher scores generally suggest responsible financial behavior, while lower scores may indicate past financial difficulties.
• Debt-to-Income Ratio: This ratio shows the applicant’s overall debt in relation to their income. An applicant with excessive debt may struggle to meet rent payments.
• Payment History: Late payments, missed payments, or accounts in collections can indicate financial instability. If an applicant has a history of paying bills on time, they’re more likely to pay rent on time as well.
• Public Records: Credit reports may reveal public records related to bankruptcies, tax liens, or civil judgments. These entries can indicate past financial issues that may impact a tenant’s ability to pay rent consistently.

Understanding these factors helps landlords avoid potential red flags and select tenants with a stable financial background. While it’s essential to remember that a credit report is only one part of the picture, it’s a crucial piece that can help you make a more informed decision.

3. How to Conduct a Tenant Credit Check

Conducting a tenant credit check is straightforward, but it requires the applicant’s written consent. Here are the general steps to follow:

1. Obtain the Applicant’s Permission: Credit checks are legally protected, meaning landlords must get written consent before pulling a report. Most rental applications include a consent form, allowing landlords to proceed with a background and credit check.
2. Choose a Credit Check Service: There are several reputable tenant screening services that provide comprehensive credit and background checks. Some popular options include TransUnion SmartMove, Experian Connect, and MyRental. These services often provide more than just a credit score, offering details about the tenant’s payment history, debt levels, and any public records.
3. Review the Report Carefully: After receiving the report, assess the tenant’s credit score, payment history, and other financial details. Pay attention to any late payments, accounts in collections, or high levels of debt. Remember to evaluate each factor in context; one or two late payments may not be dealbreakers, but a consistent pattern of financial issues might be.
4. Consider Context and Additional Information: Credit checks are valuable, but they’re not the only screening tool. It’s essential to consider the full picture by reviewing the applicant’s employment, rental history, and references. For example, a tenant with a lower credit score due to student loans may still be reliable if they have a stable job and positive rental history.

Conducting credit checks professionally and consistently helps ensure a fair process, and it demonstrates to applicants that you prioritize responsible tenancy.

4. Common Concerns and Legal Considerations

While running credit checks on tenants is essential, there are some legal and ethical considerations to keep in mind. Fair housing laws protect applicants from discrimination, and landlords must ensure they apply the same screening standards to all applicants. Avoid basing decisions solely on factors such as race, ethnicity, or other protected characteristics, as this could lead to accusations of discriminatory practices.

It’s also crucial to comply with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), which requires landlords to notify applicants if they are denied due to information found in their credit report. If you decide not to rent to an applicant based on their credit check, you’re legally required to provide an “adverse action” notice, detailing the reasons for your decision and informing the applicant of their right to view their credit report.

Additionally, some landlords worry that credit checks might discourage applicants. Address this concern by clearly explaining that credit checks are part of your standard tenant screening process. This transparency can help responsible applicants understand that you’re simply ensuring a safe, financially secure tenancy for both parties.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can I rent to someone with a low credit score?
Yes, it’s possible to rent to someone with a lower credit score if other factors, like stable income or a positive rental history, suggest they’ll be a responsible tenant. However, a low credit score can be a red flag, so consider asking for a co-signer or a higher security deposit if you choose to proceed.

2. What is an acceptable credit score for tenants?
There’s no universal “acceptable” credit score, as it varies by market and landlord preferences. Many landlords look for scores above 620, but in some cases, scores in the 600s or even lower may be acceptable, especially if the tenant has a strong income or rental history.

3. How long does a tenant credit check take?
Most tenant credit checks can be completed in minutes through online screening services. Once you have the applicant’s consent and payment, the credit check results are typically available almost instantly.

---

Running credit checks on tenants is a key step in protecting your rental property and ensuring a steady rental income. By examining a prospective tenant’s credit report, landlords can gain essential insights into their financial reliability and determine whether they’ll be a good fit for the property. When combined with a full tenant screening process, credit checks are a valuable tool for selecting tenants who will respect your property and meet their financial obligations. Following these best practices ensures a smooth, legally compliant process that helps both landlords and tenants start their rental journey on the right foot.