Pre-Screening Questions to Ask Applicants

Updated 11/05/24

Finding reliable tenants can be challenging, but effective pre-screening can make the process smoother and more efficient. By asking targeted pre-screening questions early on, landlords can avoid wasted time on applicants who might not be a good fit for the property. In this article, we’ll cover essential questions to ask and explain why pre-screening is an important step in finding trustworthy tenants.

---

Table of Contents

1. Why Pre-Screening Matters
2. Key Pre-Screening Questions to Ask Applicants
3. Benefits of Pre-Screening Applicants
4. Handling Responses to Pre-Screening Questions
5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

---

Why Pre-Screening Matters

Before investing time in a formal application process, pre-screening allows landlords to determine if an applicant meets basic qualifications. This initial step saves both time and effort, as it can quickly eliminate applicants who don’t meet the property’s requirements. It also sets clear expectations from the start, minimizing misunderstandings and helping to filter out candidates who may not be suitable.

When done effectively, pre-screening can streamline the rental process, reduce vacancy times, and help landlords focus on applicants more likely to be reliable, responsible tenants. By asking specific pre-screening questions over the phone, through email, or via an online form, landlords can gain a sense of the applicant’s compatibility with the rental property before moving on to in-depth checks.

Key Pre-Screening Questions to Ask Applicants

When developing a pre-screening process, it’s essential to ask questions that provide insight into the applicant’s financial stability, rental history, and lifestyle compatibility with the property. Here are some foundational questions to consider:

Do you meet the income requirement?
One of the primary factors in tenant screening is income stability. Ask applicants if their income meets the minimum income requirement, typically three times the rent amount. This helps ensure they can manage the monthly rent while covering other expenses.

When are you looking to move in?
Knowing the applicant’s desired move-in date is crucial. If the applicant is looking to move in months down the road while you need to fill a vacancy immediately, they may not be the right fit. Clarifying this early on saves both parties from misaligned expectations.

Why are you moving?
This question provides insight into the applicant’s rental history and reasons for leaving their current home. If an applicant mentions job relocation or a desire for more space, it often signals positive intentions. However, be cautious if they mention frequent disputes with landlords or neighbors, as these could be potential red flags.

How many people will be living in the unit?
Occupancy matters, as each rental property has limits on the number of occupants it can reasonably accommodate. Knowing the number of residents helps you determine if the applicant’s living situation aligns with your property’s capacity.

Do you have any pets?
If your property has a no-pet policy or specific pet restrictions, it’s essential to address this upfront. Understanding the type and number of pets an applicant has can prevent misunderstandings about pet fees or additional rules.

Are you okay with the rental price and deposit?
Make sure applicants are aware of the rent amount and deposit requirements and confirm they’re comfortable with these terms. If they balk at the cost, it may indicate they’re not financially prepared to commit.

Benefits of Pre-Screening Applicants

Asking pre-screening questions offers several key benefits that streamline the tenant selection process and improve the chances of finding a good match:

• Saves Time and Resources: Pre-screening minimizes the need to review applications that are unlikely to proceed further, saving time for both the landlord and applicant.
• Reduces Vacancy Time: When landlords focus on applicants who meet core requirements, they’re more likely to fill vacancies quickly, reducing lost income from empty properties.
• Improves Tenant Fit: By assessing each applicant’s compatibility with the property’s terms and conditions, landlords increase the likelihood of securing reliable, long-term tenants.

Handling Responses to Pre-Screening Questions

After gathering responses, landlords should evaluate each answer to determine the applicant’s fit for the rental. If applicants meet the basic requirements and demonstrate a stable background, landlords can proceed with confidence to the formal application and screening stages.

If an applicant doesn’t meet the pre-screening criteria, it’s courteous to communicate this politely. A simple response, such as “Thank you for your interest, but we’ve decided to move forward with other applicants who better match our requirements,” maintains professionalism and leaves a positive impression.

It’s also important to keep a record of responses to pre-screening questions, especially if multiple applicants are interested in the property. This documentation can serve as a valuable reference, allowing landlords to revisit applicant information quickly if needed.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can I charge a fee for pre-screening?
Generally, pre-screening should be free for applicants. Charging a fee may discourage potential renters from showing interest. Instead, reserve any fees for the formal application process, where background and credit checks are conducted.

2. How many pre-screening questions should I ask?
A good rule of thumb is to limit pre-screening to five to seven questions. Keep the questions focused on essential criteria, as too many questions can deter applicants.

3. What should I do if an applicant gives unclear answers?
If an applicant provides vague or incomplete responses, it’s acceptable to ask follow-up questions. Sometimes applicants might need clarification on what’s being asked. Follow-ups can help ensure you’re making an informed decision.

---

By using effective pre-screening questions, landlords can reduce time spent on unsuitable candidates and find tenants more likely to be a good match for the property. Clear, upfront communication helps set the tone for a positive landlord-tenant relationship and increases the chances of securing a reliable, long-term tenant.